The fallacy occurs in this sentence:
The Schmuckers, a family of nine who are among the 200 Amish people living in communities in Bland and Giles counties, rallied supporters who attested to their concern for animals and their desire to earn a living according to the Amish tradition.
The people who live up 42 in rural Bland County, the ones who wear the funny hats and 19th century clothing (and who smell like that's the last time they were near a bathtub), and whose male membership have the odd haircuts and plenty of facial hair (but no mustaches), and wear those cool suspenders ...
... are Mennonites. Not Amish. They's a difference.
Just thought I'd help.
* The decision comes as no surprise to the locals. Everyone gathered at Lindy's barbershop in Bland on a recent morning knew the deal was done.