Stuart Taylor on our being called "a nation of cowards":
Dear Mr. Attorney General:
Your speech commemorating Black History Month by calling America "a nation of cowards" because we "do not talk enough with each other about race" -- a topic about which we talk incessantly -- was unworthy of the admirable public servant I believe you to be.
The speech was, as others have pointed out, embarrassingly misinformed, hackneyed, and devoid of thoughtful contributions to racial dialogue.
The one point that you developed in a bit of detail in the February 18 speech was especially silly: "Black history is given a separate, and clearly not equal, treatment.... Until black history is included in the standard curriculum in our schools and becomes a regular part of all our lives, it will be viewed as a novelty, relatively unimportant and not as weighty as so-called 'real' American history."
Bosh. The reality is that our high schools and universities are quite clearly focusing disproportionate attention on black history.
The proof includes a poll published last year in which 2,000 high school juniors and seniors in all 50 states were asked to name the 10 most famous Americans, other than presidents and first ladies. The top three finishers were black: Martin Luther King Jr. (67 percent), Rosa Parks (60 percent), and Harriet Tubman (44 percent). So is the only living finisher, Oprah Winfrey (22 percent).
As for the universities, "the almost obsessive emphasis on race, class, and gender in the humanities and social sciences means that, if anything, black history is overrepresented in college history curricula," in the words of professor KC Johnson, a distinguished scholar of American history based at Brooklyn College.
To the contrary, this nation has adopted numerous civil-rights laws. It has replaced the once-pervasive regime of discrimination against blacks with a benignly motivated but nonetheless wide-reaching regime of discrimination against whites, euphemistically known as "affirmative action." It sometimes seems more interested in teaching children about slavery and segregation than about math and science. It has elected a black president.
For all of its flaws, this nation is "the least racist white-majority society in the world; has a better record of legal protection of minorities than any other society, white or black; [and] offers more opportunities to a greater number of black persons than any other society, including all those of Africa," black sociologist Orlando Patterson wrote in 1991.
It'll do no good to bring all this up, Stuart. These people are fixated on the subjects of oppression and lack of opportunity. And you'll not get through to them.
The point hit home a number of years ago, in a very startling - laughable - way when I watched a Bryant Gumbel "Today Show" interview with movie director Spike Lee (both black). Lee, as is his norm, began his "America is a racist gulag" schtick, and told Gumbel that a black man has no chance of achieving the American dream, a declaration to which Gumbel agreed.
This from two of the most successful and wealthy men on the planet. Both Americans.
I knew right then that "dialogue" with these jokers was pointless. And hopeless. They live(d) in a world of illusion, detached from all reality. That detachment continues.
Stuart Taylor is right, of course. We've talked ourselves blue in the face about race in this country. And the Gumbels/Lees/Holders of this world don't see it.
So maybe the answer is to stop talking about it. And get back to living our lives. Want to "dialogue" about the color of one's skin and its implications? Leave me out. I've got a productive life to live.